Best Chew Toys for Irish Setters

By PetEssentialist Editorial · Updated July 2026

We independently research and pick every product. When you buy through our links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. How this works.

🏆 Quick answer

Our top pick is KONG Extreme Dog Toy — best for Powerful chewers. Why it wins: Ultra-durable for powerful chewers.

Irish Setters are known for their energetic and playful nature, but this enthusiasm can also lead to destructive chewing if not directed towards suitable outlets. With their large size and powerful jaws, Irish Setters require chew toys that are not only durable but also safe, to prevent choking hazards. Their high energy levels mean they need toys that can keep up with their activity, providing mental and physical stimulation. The breed's size and jaw power are critical factors in selecting the right chew toys. Irish Setters typically weigh between 60-70 lbs, with a corresponding bite force that demands near-indestructible toys to withstand their chewing. Furthermore, their large size means that toys must be appropriately scaled to prevent choking, emphasizing the need for choke-safe designs. Given these considerations, the search for the perfect chew toy for an Irish Setter becomes a quest for the ideal balance between durability, size, and safety. The toys must be capable of withstanding the breed's powerful chewing while also being large enough to not pose a choking risk.

What to look for

Chew Toy Durability

Irish Setters are powerful chewers, so the chew toy must be ultra-durable to withstand their jaw power. Toys made from tough materials like rubber or nylon are preferable.

Size and Choke Safety

Given the Irish Setter's large size, it's crucial that chew toys are scaled appropriately to prevent choking hazards. Toys that are too small can be swallowed, so opting for larger, choke-safe designs is essential.

Energy Level and Stimulation

Irish Setters have high energy levels and need toys that can provide both mental and physical stimulation. Toys that can be stuffed with treats or have multiple textures can keep them engaged for longer periods.

Health Considerations

While selecting chew toys, it's also important to consider the breed's health issues, such as hip dysplasia, which may affect their mobility and comfort while playing. Lightweight toys may be preferable for dogs with mobility issues.

Our top picks

SponsoredHow we choose →

#	Product	Best for
1	KONG Extreme Dog Toy	Powerful chewers
2	Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy	Dogs needing flavorful stimulation
3	Nylabone Power Chew Dog Toy	Dogs requiring long-lasting interest
4	West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Dog Bone	Dogs enjoying water play
5	GoughNuts Maxx 50 STOP Chew Dog Toy Ring	The most aggressive and powerful chewers

KONG Extreme Dog Toy

Best for Powerful chewers

The KONG Extreme Dog Toy is designed for the most powerful chewers, making it an ideal match for Irish Setters. Its ultra-durable black rubber and hollow core for stuffing make it perfect for withstanding aggressive chewing while providing mental stimulation. The toy's large size options ensure it's safe for Irish Setters, reducing the risk of choking.

✓ Ultra-durable for powerful chewers
✓ Hollow core for mental stimulation
✓ Large size options for safety

✕ May be too durable for less aggressive chewers

Check price →

Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy

Best for Dogs needing flavorful stimulation

The Benebone Real Flavor Wishbone Dog Chew Toy offers real food ingredients infused throughout, which can be very appealing to Irish Setters. The ergonomic wishbone shape makes it easy for them to grip, and the durable nylon construction can withstand their chewing. However, owners should ensure they choose the appropriate size to prevent choking hazards.

✓ Real food ingredients for flavor
✓ Ergonomic shape for easy gripping
✓ Durable construction

✕ May not be suitable for the most aggressive chewers

Check price →

Nylabone Power Chew Dog Toy

Best for Dogs requiring long-lasting interest

The Nylabone Power Chew Dog Toy is designed for long-lasting interest with its flavored nylon. The textured ridges also help clean teeth while chewing, which is beneficial for Irish Setters. However, owners must select the correct size based on their dog's weight to ensure safety and effectiveness.

✓ Flavored nylon for long-lasting interest
✓ Textured ridges for dental health
✓ Variety of flavors

✕ Size selection is crucial to prevent choking

Check price →

West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Dog Bone

Best for Dogs enjoying water play

The West Paw Zogoflex Hurley Dog Bone is perfect for Irish Setters who enjoy water play, as it floats in water. Made from durable, non-toxic Zogoflex material, it's also dishwasher safe, making it a convenient option for owners. However, the size options may not be as extensive as other toys, requiring careful selection to ensure choke safety.

✓ Floats in water for aquatic play
✓ Durable and non-toxic
✓ Dishwasher safe

✕ Limited size options may not fit all Irish Setters

Check price →

GoughNuts Maxx 50 STOP Chew Dog Toy Ring

Best for The most aggressive and powerful chewers

The GoughNuts Maxx 50 STOP Chew Dog Toy Ring is virtually indestructible, making it suitable for the most aggressive chewers among Irish Setters. The red inner indicator layer provides a safety feature, signaling when the toy needs to be replaced. However, its specific design for powerful chewers may make it less appealing to dogs with less aggressive chewing habits.

✓ Virtually indestructible for aggressive chewers
✓ Safety indicator for replacement

✕ May not be engaging for less powerful chewers

Check price →

Frequently asked questions

What makes a chew toy suitable for an Irish Setter?

A suitable chew toy for an Irish Setter should be durable enough to withstand their powerful jaws, large enough to prevent choking hazards, and provide mental and physical stimulation.

How often should I replace my Irish Setter's chew toys?

The frequency of replacing chew toys depends on the toy's durability and the dog's chewing habits. If a toy shows signs of significant wear or the manufacturer indicates it's time for replacement, it's best to get a new one to prevent health risks.

Can Irish Setters chew on rawhide?

While rawhide can be a popular choice for some dogs, it's not recommended for aggressive chewers like Irish Setters due to the risk of choking or intestinal blockage if large pieces are swallowed.

What are the signs that my Irish Setter needs a new chew toy?

Signs that your Irish Setter needs a new chew toy include the toy being severely damaged, showing signs of wear that could lead to choking hazards, or if your dog seems to have lost interest in the toy, indicating it no longer provides sufficient stimulation.

How can I prevent my Irish Setter from destroying household items?

To prevent your Irish Setter from destroying household items, provide them with a variety of durable chew toys that cater to their chewing needs. Supervise their playtime, and engage them in activities that redirect their energy away from household items.

For Irish Setter owners, the key to choosing the right chew toy lies in balancing durability, size, and the ability to provide mental and physical stimulation. The KONG Extreme Dog Toy is a top recommendation for powerful chewers, offering ultra-durability and a hollow core for stuffing. Regardless of the toy chosen, ensuring it's appropriate for the dog's size and chewing power is crucial for their safety and enjoyment.

More for your Irish Setter

Other breed-matched picks worth a look.

Best Chew Toys for other breeds

The same category, matched to a different breed.