Best Toys for American Shorthairs

We independently research and pick every product. When you buy through our links we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. How this works.

American Shorthairs are known for their easygoing and adaptable nature, but they still require stimulation to prevent boredom and obesity. With a moderate energy level, they need toys that challenge them physically and mentally. Their intelligence and prey drive make them natural hunters, and they thrive on interactive play. Their play style is characterized by short bursts of energy, making toys that encourage quick movements and reactions ideal. Additionally, their moderate intelligence means they can solve simple puzzles and enjoy problem-solving toys. When it comes to toys, American Shorthairs need a mix of physical and mental stimulation to keep them engaged and active. The right toys can help prevent health issues such as obesity and dental disease, while also providing entertainment and enjoyment.

What to look for

Energy Level

American Shorthairs have a moderate energy level, requiring toys that provide a balance of physical and mental stimulation. Toys that encourage short bursts of energy and quick movements are ideal. Consider toys with feathers, strings, or other attachments that mimic prey, allowing your cat to engage in natural hunting behavior.

Intelligence and Problem-Solving

American Shorthairs are moderately intelligent and enjoy solving simple puzzles. Toys that challenge them to figure out how to get a treat or toy out are perfect for keeping them engaged and stimulated. Look for toys with hidden compartments or puzzle pieces that require problem-solving skills.

Prey Drive

American Shorthairs have a strong prey drive, and toys that mimic small animals or birds are ideal. Consider toys with feathers, strings, or other attachments that allow your cat to engage in natural hunting behavior. This will help satisfy their instinctual needs and provide entertainment.

Safety and Durability

American Shorthairs are medium-sized cats, and their toys should be sturdy and durable to withstand their play. Look for toys made from high-quality materials that can resist chewing and scratching. Additionally, ensure that toys are choke-safe and do not have small parts that can be easily detached.

Variety and Rotation

American Shorthairs can get bored with the same toys, so it's essential to rotate them regularly. Consider a variety of toys that cater to different aspects of their personality, such as hunting, problem-solving, and physical activity. This will keep them engaged and stimulated, preventing boredom and obesity.

Our top picks

Go Cat Da Bird Feather Teaser Wand Toy

Best for stimulating natural prey drive

The Go Cat Da Bird Feather Teaser Wand Toy is an excellent choice for American Shorthairs, as it mimics the movement of small animals and birds, triggering their natural prey drive. The realistic spinning feather lure encourages interactive play, providing entertainment and exercise. This toy is perfect for American Shorthairs, as it caters to their moderate energy level and intelligence.

✓ Stimulates natural prey drive
✓ Encourages interactive play
✓ Durable and sturdy

✕ May be too intense for some cats

Check price →

Catit Senses 2.0 Circuit Ball Track Toy

Best for problem-solving and hunting instinct

The Catit Senses 2.0 Circuit Ball Track Toy is a great choice for American Shorthairs, as it challenges them to solve a simple puzzle and hunt for the ball. The expandable and configurable design allows for varying levels of difficulty, keeping your cat engaged and stimulated. This toy is perfect for American Shorthairs, as it caters to their moderate intelligence and problem-solving skills.

✓ Challenges problem-solving skills
✓ Stimulates hunting instinct
✓ Expandable and configurable

✕ May be too complex for some cats

Check price →

Yeowww! Catnip Banana Cat Toy

Best for relaxation and sensory stimulation

The Yeowww! Catnip Banana Cat Toy is a great choice for American Shorthairs, as it provides a potent and relaxing catnip experience. The durable cotton twill and perfect size for bunny-kicking make it an excellent toy for gentle play and sensory stimulation. This toy is perfect for American Shorthairs, as it caters to their easygoing and adaptable nature.

✓ Potent and relaxing catnip experience
✓ Durable and sturdy
✓ Perfect size for bunny-kicking

✕ May be too potent for some cats

Check price →

Petstages Tower of Tracks Interactive Cat Toy

Best for physical activity and hunting instinct

The Petstages Tower of Tracks Interactive Cat Toy is a great choice for American Shorthairs, as it provides a fun and challenging way to stimulate their physical activity and hunting instinct. The three stacked levels with spinning balls encourage paw-batting and problem-solving, keeping your cat engaged and entertained. This toy is perfect for American Shorthairs, as it caters to their moderate energy level and intelligence.

✓ Stimulates physical activity and hunting instinct
✓ Encourages paw-batting and problem-solving
✓ Non-slip base

✕ May be too complex for some cats

Check price →

PetSafe Bolt Interactive Laser Cat Toy

Best for entertainment and physical activity

The PetSafe Bolt Interactive Laser Cat Toy is a great choice for American Shorthairs, as it provides a fun and entertaining way to stimulate their physical activity. The automatic randomized laser patterns and 15-minute auto shutoff make it an excellent toy for hands-free play and entertainment. This toy is perfect for American Shorthairs, as it caters to their moderate energy level and intelligence.

✓ Stimulates physical activity and entertainment
✓ Automatic randomized laser patterns
✓ Hands-free play

✕ May be too intense for some cats

Check price →

Frequently asked questions

What type of toys are best for American Shorthairs?

American Shorthairs thrive on interactive toys that challenge them physically and mentally, such as feather wands, puzzle toys, and catnip-filled mice. They also enjoy problem-solving toys and those that mimic small animals or birds.

How often should I rotate my cat's toys?

It's essential to rotate your cat's toys regularly to prevent boredom and keep them engaged. Aim to introduce new toys or rotate existing ones every 1-2 weeks to keep your cat stimulated and entertained.

Are laser toys suitable for American Shorthairs?

Laser toys can be suitable for American Shorthairs, but it's essential to introduce them gradually and in moderation. Some cats may become overstimulated or frustrated with laser toys, so it's crucial to monitor their behavior and adjust playtime accordingly.

Can American Shorthairs play with toys that are too small or too large for them?

No, it's essential to choose toys that are the right size for your American Shorthair. Toys that are too small can be a choking hazard, while those that are too large may be difficult for your cat to maneuver. Opt for toys that are specifically designed for medium-sized cats like American Shorthairs.

How can I encourage my American Shorthair to play more?

To encourage your American Shorthair to play more, try introducing new toys or rotating existing ones regularly. You can also try engaging in interactive play with your cat, such as using a feather wand or laser pointer. Additionally, make sure your cat is getting enough exercise and mental stimulation to prevent boredom and obesity.

When it comes to choosing the best toys for your American Shorthair, consider their moderate energy level, intelligence, and prey drive. Opt for toys that provide a mix of physical and mental stimulation, such as interactive wand toys, puzzle toys, and catnip-filled mice. By choosing the right toys and rotating them regularly, you can keep your American Shorthair entertained, stimulated, and healthy. Remember to prioritize your cat's health and consider pet insurance to cover unexpected veterinary bills.

More for your American Shorthair

Other breed-matched picks worth a look.

Best Toys for other breeds

The same category, matched to a different breed.